Ruben Rome: I had this pack set up exactly the same way as you when hiking yesterday,
and I have to say it's the most uncomfortable, painful rucksack I've ever
had. Not sure what I'm doing wrong as I had the hip bones right in the
middle of the belt and they became incredibly sore, to the point of
numbness, from the pressure. I also had trouble with too much pressure on
the shoulders and chest. Any suggestions?
Shortgunkiller: Great Review Andy! I'm gonna buy one. so I'd like to know one thing about
the shoulder harness and load lifter strap. Is it strong enough for the
Rozana Afi: hi andy. good review :) i just want to know, is the top of the bag can be
extended to be high?
91hursty: Hi great review, I'm Going to buy a new pack soon and i was wondering
whether you think this kestrel 68 is better than the aether 70? The aether
70 is 30 pounds more expensive ( i'm from the UK ) and it has less pockets
and no rain cover. thanks.
aegis1337: Multiple water container devices in case of failure. CamelBaks can burst. I
use a stainless steel Nalgene that I boil water in as well so it doubles in
Andrew McManama: Hey there hursty! Thanks for the review. The aether is a good pack as well.
It has the same air escape padding on the back as the kestrel. The aether
is more customizable when it comes to fitting and has an add on attachment
for the daylite pack. Personally I like the kestrel because I am pretty
average in my size so I don't need to customize the fit. And I love extra
pockets! It's nice having the rain cover as well. I'd go for the kestrel if
you like the way it fits.
ProteanView: Great review. Like to see a bag reviewed when it's full. Appreciate the
tips about loading pockets & bladder, as well as how to put it on.
Scott Stith: Andy, thanks for the review, this looks like a great pack! Similar question
to hursty but I'm thinking about this Kestrel over the Atmos 65 for price,
included rain fly and your positive review. What do you think? Thanks!
Andrew McManama: Hello Rozana, thanks for watching. This pack does not extend much higher
than it is here. Maybe a bit more, but you's sacrifice the ability to fully
close the main compartment. It really does have a lot of capacity though,
more wide than tall.....
aegis1337: I utilize my 1L Nalgene bottle on my Kestrel 58's side pocket. I think it's
a bit disconcerting that the woven mesh stretches so much to accommodate it
but I utilize the strap on the outside to secure it even further. I've had
my fully loaded bag with Nalgene in that side pocket loaded beneath buses
and jostled around and it was secure. Good luck with whatever direction you
Andrew McManama: It claims to hold up to 55 lbs. I have had 40 in it with no issues. It
carries the load very comfortably.
streetspiritben: Why not use a camel back bladder?
SoCalDaveL: Great review AJ. I'm sold on Osprey.. also going back & forth between the
Kestrel (my 1st fave), Atmos 65 & Aether 70. The Kestrel is a great fit at
a more reasonable price. I tried them all on at a local REI. My biggest
concern came when adding a standard 1L Nalgene bottle to the side pockets..
didn't hold well walking around the store. Might hold better once the bag
is fully loaded. Any thoughts/comments? A water bottle should decide my
pack, but my pack should accomodate my gear. Thnx
Chris Bergst: I think exterior gusseted pockets would be nice to make the interior really
the advertised size. Nice review. Seems like the Kestrel 68 is right for
Tom Smith: 'Here I'm carrying my water shoes'.... A bit later he says 'There will be
no water sources on this trip' Hang on ;) whaaat? but seriously thanks for
the review, pretty informative :)
Andrew McManama: Sorry for delayed response, I've been using the Kestrel! My buddy has the
Atmos and he loves it. We both have wet backs at the end of a hot day, but
not soaking. The Atmos is also lighter I believe. IMHO you can't go wrong
with either. I saw more Atmos' on the trail than Kestrels.....
Andrew McManama: Thanks! Enjoy your new pack. I am itching to get mine out again!
Andrew McManama: Thanks for watching! The Atmos is a very nice pack as well. I've seen it in
action first hand. It is more customizable as fit goes, so If you fall
outside of the measurements for a kestrel s/m or m/l you want to go atmos.
The Atmos also has a more breathable vent system for your back so you'll
sweat less. But The kestrel still breathes just fine, I've done plenty of
hikes with it and remained dry. My bias says Kestrel for the rain cover and
price, but untimely it is up to you.
teejate: Good review. And to follow up on your question to the reviewer about the
vent system I had a smaller Stratos with the same AirSpeed suspension as
the Atmos. Didn't care for it. I didn't sweat any less although I'm a big
sweat-er so it wouldn't have mattered, but it was the serious squeak that
developed in the stabilizing rods that drove me nuts. Enough that I had to
send it back when silicone didn't take care of it. All Osprey packs are
quality but the Kestral would be by choice between the two
ayokay123: Thanks for the response. :)
Chris Cox: Great review, cheers Andy. I bought the 2012 version today and will be
trying it out next week.
ayokay123: Any thoughts on the Kestrel 68 vs. the Atmos 65? I know the air suspension
is a bit deeper on the Atmos.